Fate and Free Will in The Aeneid and Inferno: Aeneas and Creusa
Need help with Book 2 in Virgil's The Aeneid? Check out our Priam unbinds Sinon and asks about the purpose of the horse. Sinon says the horse is an. The ghost of Creusa, whom Aeneas encountered toward the end of the preceding For example, the Trojans perform religious rites in connection with oracular. Analysis of Dido's and Aeneas' vision aids in analyzing their relationship; both It can suggest the physical aspect ofsight, a future aspiration or goal, or even a as Creusa, whose imago appears before Aeneas Obviously, the term imago.
Nescius Aeneas, entirely concerned with his father, is still forgetful of his mission, still anchored to the past. Henry 41 observes: Its importance is manifested by its position at the closure of the Iliupersis, by the language that divinizes her figure, by a refined web of references to the previous apparitions of Hector Aen. Throughout Book Two, explicit narrative links and linguistic echoes design a path and mark significant evolutions.
Both Hector and Venus are close to Aeneas and appear to him in difficult moments, when a critical situation requires him to change his plan of action. They both make it clear that Aeneas can accomplish nothing any longer, and with similar words they urge him to escape. Heu fuge, nate dea, teque his — ait — eripe flammis Aen. Eripe, nate, fugam finemque impone labori Aen.
But the differences are also clear. The two also differ in how they deal with Aeneas: Hector literally cuts him short with nec me quaerentem vana moratur Aen. Venus appears instead as propitious divine mother alma parens, Aen. She asks why Aeneas is so angry quid furis? For the evolution of the prophecies to Aeneas in Aen. Ve- nus as well speaks of divum inclementia Aen.
Hector, spes fidissima Teucrum 2. In short, while Troy falls Hector and Venus remind Aeneas of different spheres of duties: Hector, who gave up his life and even after his death remained loyal to his civic obligations, worries for the destiny of Troy; while Venus, who reminds Aeneas of the obligations that bound him to his relatives, worries for his family.
In each situation Aeneas is caught off guard by the vision of a beloved individual, as he passes from quies Hector to furor Venus to dolor Creusa. Like her predecessors, Creusa invites Aeneas to accept his destiny lacrimas dilectae pelle Creusae Aen.
Venus speaks about the inclementia divum Aen. Creusa, talking about her loss, echoes Venus and states: Creusa speaks about longa exilia Aen. Also immediately after the difficult-to-accept mention of the exile, she speaks of res laetae attending him. Nate, quid indomitas tantus dolor excitat iras?
Both appeal to Aeneas in the name of the link they have with him and ask the reason for such great pain, gently inviting him to calm down.
Both are sad about the past but hopeful about the future: Hector is maestissimus Aen. Sacra suosque tibi commendat Troia penatis; hos cape fatorum comites, his moenia quaere magna, pererrato statues quae denique ponto. Aeneas asks no more questions, and those he asked before remain unanswered Aen.
For Creusa, see Aen. Nusquam abero et tutum patrio te limine sistam Aen. Iamque vale et nati serva communis amorem Aen. What she says Aen. See also Conington ad Aen. There in store for you are happy days, kingship, and a royal wife. Banish tears for your beloved Creusa. For the first time in the poem Aeneas hears the destination of his mission: After a glimpse at the difficult part of his long exile, Creusa promises res laetae, a kingdom and a royal wife.
She is even willing to support him and to yield to his next wife. Her disappearance constitutes the natural conclusion and climax of Book Two, and her vision represents a pivotal moment in the architecture of the Aeneid. Aeneas, however, is still far from accepting his mission and fulfilling his obligations, as the episode of Dido will tragically show. The comparison with Hector plays very unfavorably for Aeneas: On the other is Aeneas, for whom the model of Hector is out 73 Henry 9 states: The internal narrator, who confesses to being still confused about the details of the loss, and the ambiguity of the language prevent a clear reconstruction of the sequence: In the loss of Creusa this unawareness is mixed with a strong feeling of disappointment et comites natumque virumque fefellit, Aen.
Vergili Maronis Aeneidos Liber Secundus. Studies in the Eclogues, Georgics, and Aeneid. A note on structure in Virgil. Praise, Poetry and the Novelization of the Aeneid. Bakhtin and the Other, edited by Peter I. Conington, John and Nettleship, Henry eds. The Rhetoric of Imitation. Empirical and Theoretical Approaches to Literary Genre.
Gender, Textuality and the Medieval Aeneid. The Gods in Epic. Haunted Greece and Rome: Ghost Stories from Classical Antiquity. Readings in Postmodern Latin. The Vigour of Prophecy: Self-telling and Theodicy in Aeneid 2. An Interpretive Guide, edited by Christine Perkell, pp.
Women in Latin Epic. Roman Social and Political Val- ues in the Epic. A Study in Civilized Poetry. Vergili Maroni Aeneidos Liber Quartus. Les origines de la legende troyenne de Rome. The Child and the Hero: Coming of Age in Catullus and Vergil. Italic, Latin, Italian, B. Though the Trojan seer Cassandra tries to alert the Trojans to their impending doom, the Trojans don't listen to her, celebrating the horse and throwing a big party.
During the party, Sinon, hidden by Fate, opens the horse, releasing Ulysses and other Greek warriors. Meanwhile the Greek fleet returns to the Trojan shores. Why did the serpents come and attack Laocoon and his sons? Virgil doesn't mention a specific god sending them—they're more like agents of fate. This scene shows a miscarriage of piety and religion. The Trojans choose their favorite interpretations, and don't realize that their devotion and respect are based on an incorrect assessment of events.
The bloody ghost of Hector, a great, deceased Trojan warrior, appears to Aeneas in a dream and warns Aeneas of a fire and the enemy within the city. Troy cannot be saved, Hector says, and Aeneas should take the household gods and find a new home. Aeneas wakes, hearing screaming and sounds of fighting in the streets.
On the street, Aeneas meets Panthus, a seer who has given up hope for Troy. Aeneas, in a panicked rage about the battle, neglects Hector's advice and joins the fight. This is the first time that Aeneas learns that he will have to leave, wander the seas and found a new home. Bringing the household gods means that he can preserve Troy's legacy. Throughout the poem, home is closely tied to ideas of Troy.
Aeneas, Anchises, and Ascanius - Wikipedia
Aeneas will always carry the past with him. They kill many Greeks, but then the Trojans, not recognizing them, fire on them, and many die, including Panthus. The Greeks begin to attack the royal palace, and Aeneas rallies the Trojan troops against them. Aeneas then describes Pyrrhus, the Greek warrior and son of Achilles, and says he was like a snake that hid and grew huge in the winter and now reveals itself. Pyrrhus and his comrades break into the palace, like an overflowing river. By disguising himself, Aeneas resembles trickster Greeks such as Sinon and Ulysses.
He's willing to play dirty to fight for his home and his friends—another sign of his piety, but one that shows how his moral judgment might change based on his situation. The comparison of Pyrrhus to a snake suggests that his evil is beyond human. Active Themes In the palace sits Priam, the aged king, who had put on his rusty armor and bravely attempted to fight even though Hecuba, his wife, begged him to stay with her in safety.
Pyrrhus kills Polites, one of Priam's sons. Despite being in mortal danger, Priam rebukes Pyrrhus for killing his son, and, despite his weakness, throws his spear at Pyrrhus.
Pyrrhus mercilessly kills Priam, telling him to complain to Achilles in the underworld about his bad behavior. Aeneas, horrified, fears for the safety of his own father, wife, and son.
This scene shows the extreme importance of family in Aeneas's world. He starts to burn down King Latinus' city, to root out the resistance once and for all. Queen Amata hangs herself.
Turnus tells his sister to stop interfering, because fate has won, and he wants to fight Aeneas honorably before he dies. Turnus and Aeneas begin to duel, and Jupiter holds up his scales to confirm their fates.
Turnus' sword breaks; he panics and runs away, Aeneas pursuing. However, gods are still interfering. Juturna hands the fleeing Turnus a sword, while Venus pulls Aeneas' spear free from a tree it had lodged in.
Jupiter is fed up by now and confronts Juno, who finally gives up, asking only that the ensuing people be called Latins and the Trojans lose their identity. Jupiter agrees to create a single Latin race from the two warring peoples. Jupiter sends two Furies to chase Juturna away from Turnus, and Aeneas throws his spear, wounding Turnus. Turnus begs for his life, but Aeneas sees the belt of dead Pallas on Turnus and, enraged, kills Turnus. Piety for Aeneas did not mean faith so much as obedience and careful attention to the will of the gods, especially Jupiter, so that he could do the right thing in the right way.
This piety expressed itself in right relations to the gods, to ones family, and to the state, as well as in carrying out rituals in a correct, thoughtful manner. Pious Aeneas carries his household gods from Troy to Italy; he holds Memorial Games for Anchises; he immediately obeys Mercury's message to leave Dido.
Steadfast He feels Dido's grief, but is unmoved in his actions. Compassionate He stops the boxing match when Entellus is overwhelming Dares; he grieves for his dead soldiers. Fair He awards the prizes fairly during the memorial games. Brave He fights bravely at Troy, only stopping because Venus tells him to leave; he is equally brave combating Turnus in Latium.
Willing to cooperate with Destiny He learns the future in the Underworld and acts willingly to bring it about. Paternal It is Aeneas' fatherly duty to Ascanius to leave Dido and found a new nation for his descendants. A Leader Aeneas soothes his weary followers after the storm, "our god will give an end to this as well"; he is concerned with feeding and comforting them; in Italy he forms alliances and leads the fighting. Emotional Aeneas narrates the fall of Troy with great feeling, such as, "the first time savage horror took me" II Passion and Politics Dido is not just a nice lady who has hard luck with love.
Not only does Virgil explain that Cupid poisons Dido with love, but he also gives us plenty of hints about Dido's potential for danger to Aeneas, such as her fury when she is about to kill herself: And could I not have dragged his body off, and scattered him piecemeal upon the waters, limb by limb? Or butchered all his comrades, even served Ascanius himself as banquet dish upon his father's table?
Indeed, Dido's funeral pyre itself is chock full of elements of witchcraft, not approved practice in Roman court circles. However, Virgil also portrays Dido's love for Aeneas with such sympathy that readers appreciate her love, hate Aeneas for leaving her, and mostly ignore the negative undertone.
Creusa of Troy
Dido is largely modelled on two ancient, very bad women--Cleopatra and Medea in the Argonautica of Apollonius Rhodius. Virgil presents her as the epitome of the decadent, treacherous Orient as opposed to the noble Roman West. She and Antony are part of the center of the shield of Aeneas, with their barbarian troops and barbaric gods, opposing the true leaders of Rome and the household gods brought to Italy by Aeneas.
At one level, Aeneas' affair with Dido is the crossing point--he has left the Orient Troyand is delayed by one last Oriental experience decadent passionbefore going forth to become the Latin ancestor of the Roman people.
Medea, in the Argonautica, fell quickly and madly in love with Jason and betrayed her father to please Jason, helping him through trickery and witchcraft to acquire the Golden Fleece.
Afraid of her father's anger, Medea ran off with Jason; she also lured her half-brother Apsyrtus to Jason who killed him. This was just part of her notorious career as a passionate woman and a witch.
A Roman reader would have recognized unpleasant echoes of Medea in Virgil's Dido. The list is headed by the raging goddess Juno and the raging warrior Turnus. It includes the Harpies, Allecto, Amata, the Trojan Women burning their ships, and the Latins in general when in battle frenzy. Even Aeneas is touched by passionate fury twice: Passion spreads like a virus. Venus uses Cupid to infect Dido with the passion of love.
Juno uses Allecto to infect Amata, Turnus and the Latin masses with the passion for war. In every case except for, perhaps, Aeneas' final passionate killing of Turnus, passion opposes the will of Jupiter, Destiny and Fate.
This alone shows us how little Virgil approved of such intense emotion. But there is also Destiny, the notion that there is a necessary future to strive towards. This is the fate that Jupiter upholds, a pattern that is not a simple working out of conflicts. Juno and Venus act in opposition to the necessary path of the fates. They know perfectly well what must come to pass, because Jupiter tells them, but each has her own passionate agenda, one the irrational, intense love of a mother for her son, the other raw frenzied hatred of the Trojans whose descendants will destroy Carthage.