Logan killicks and janie relationship with god

Story behind the story of “Their Eyes Were Watching God” | Choucair’s English

logan killicks and janie relationship with god

Janie formed her initial idea of marriage off the image of From her marriage to Logan Killicks to Tea Cake. Janie and Joe Starks' relationship is very different. He thinks that Janie, as woman, should be sitting on the porch, not getting her hands dirty. A wealthy farmer and land-owner, Logan Killick's is Janie's first husband. Their marriage is arranged by Janie's grandmother Nanny, a former slave who desires .

So this was marriage!

Their Eyes Were Watching God

With kissing bees singing of the beginning of the world! Janie was forced be Nanny to marry Logan Killicks for her financial stability.

logan killicks and janie relationship with god

Maybe if somebody was to tell me how, Ah could do it. Janie learned from her marriage to Jody Starks that she needs to think about her happiness and that a married couple should see each other as equals. Janie fell in love with Jody because of his big plans and his success. Jody treated Janie as an accessory, a bonus to his success.

logan killicks and janie relationship with god

Jody only wanted Janie to make him look good. Janie recognized when she married Tea Cake that, although she had gone through two marriages without love, true love could be found. Janie was very careful when falling for Tea Cake. She took her time and made sure he was the right person for her.

She knew she wanted someone she was going to love on her own, not forced, and someone that was going to treat her as an equal. Tea Cake treated her as an equal. Finding the small town residents unambitious, Starks arranges to buy more land, establishes a general store which he has built by local residents, and is soon elected as mayor of the town.

logan killicks and janie relationship with god

Janie soon realises that Starks wants her as a trophy wifeto reinforce his powerful position in town. He asks her to run the store, but forbids her from participating in the substantial social life that occurs on the store's front porch.

He treats her as his property, controlling what she wears and says, and criticizes her mistakes. He also begins to strike her occasionally. As time passes, he teases her in public about being old, even though she is only in her thirties. Eventually, she cannot bear it and snaps back at Joe to look at himself. Starks hits her as hard as he can.

  • Story behind the story of “Their Eyes Were Watching God”
  • Story behind the story of “Their Eyes Were Watching God”
  • Their Eyes Were Watching God: Marriages & Analysis

Later, he gets sick, and refuses to let Janie see him. He does not realize that he has a failing kidney, a likely fatal illness. When Janie learns that he might die, she goes to talk to him. She tells him who she really is and says that he never knew because he would not let her be free. After Starks dies, Janie becomes financially independent through his estate. She is beset with suitors, some of whom are men of some means or have prestigious occupations, and all of whom she turns down.

She meets a young drifter and gambler named Vergible Woods who goes by the name "Tea Cake". Tea Cake plays the guitar for her and initially treats her with kindness and respect. At first Janie is doubtful of his affections, as she is older and has wealth, but eventually falls in love with him.

Deciding to run away with him, Janie has a friend look after the store, and the two head to Jacksonville to marry. They move to the Everglades region "the muck" where they find work planting and harvesting beans.

While their relationship has its ups and downs, including mutual bouts of jealousy and an episode in which Tea Cake whips Janie in order to demonstrate his possession of her, Janie realizes she now has the marriage with love that she's always wanted; her image of the pear tree blossom is revived.

However, the area is hit by the great Okeechobee hurricaneand in the chaos of surviving, Tea Cake is bitten by a rabid dog while saving Janie from drowning, and he contracts the disease. While the disease runs its course, he becomes increasingly jealous and unpredictable despite Janie's best efforts. He ultimately tries to shoot Janie with his pistol, and she is forced to shoot him first with a rifle in self-defense. She is charged with murder. At the trial, Tea Cake's black male friends show up to oppose her, but a group of local white women arrive to support Janie.

The all-white jury acquits Janie, and she gives Tea Cake a lavish funeral. Tea Cake's friends are apologetic and forgive her, wanting her to remain in the Everglades. However, she decides to return to Eatonville. As she expected, the residents gossip about her when she arrives back in town.

The story ends where it started, and Janie finishes telling her story to Pheoby. Gender Roles[ edit ] The novel explores traditional gender roles and the relationship between men and women.

Nanny believes that Janie should marry a man not for love but for 'protection'. Logan Killicks and Jody Starks both believe Janie should be defined by her marriage to them. Both men want her to be domesticated and silent. Her speech, or silence, is defined by her physical locations, most often. For example, Joe forces her silence in the store, a public—and therefore, male—space.

Their eyes were watching god - Relationship Compare and Contrast by Dustin Riecke on Prezi

Muh wife don't know nothin' bout no speech-makin'. Ah never married her for nothin' lak dat. She's uh woman and her place is in de home. Her place is seen as in the home and not out on the porch, a public space which can be defined as male. Tea Cake is Janie's last husband who treats her as more of an equal than Killicks and Starks did, by talking to her and playing checkers with her.

Despite his equal treatment in the beginning, Tea Cake does hit Janie in order to show his possession over her. Thus, Janie's life seems defined by her relation to male-centric spaces. Liberated Woman[ edit ] Janie is searching for her own identity throughout the novel. Throughout the book, Janie is often without a voice when it comes to her husbands as she will not fight back.

She is seen as separated from the other women in the novel who follow the traditions in place and do not find a life independent of men. Janie's womanliness is a source of jealousy for both Starks and Tea Cake who shame her for her looks.

Starks orders Janie to cover her hair as other men found it a source of attraction. Similarly, Tea Cake is conscious of Janie's lighter skin and her appeal to Mrs. Janie finds her independence as a woman after the death of Tea Cake. She returns to Eatonville with her hair down and she sits on her own porch chatting with her friend Pheoby.

She has overcome the traditional roles of a woman by the end of the novel, thereby cultivating an image of the "liberated black woman. By doing so, she takes the reader on a journey through Janie's life and her marriages. Janie formed her initial idea of marriage off the image of unity she witnessed between a pear tree and a bee. This image and expectation sets Janie up for disappointment when it finally came time to marry. From her marriage to Logan Killicks to Tea Cake, Janie was forced to acknowledge where she stood as a female in her relationship.

Starting with her marriage to Logan, Janie was put in a place where she was expected to work. On top of all the physical labor expected from her, Janie endured physical beatings from her male counterpart. Hoping for more value, Janie decides to leave Logan and run off with Joe Starks.

logan killicks and janie relationship with god

However, in reaction to this decision, she's only faced with more beating and devaluement. Joe expected her stay in the home, work in the kitchen, and when she was in public, Janie was expected to cover her hair and avoid conversation with the locals.

With one last hope, Janie engaged in a marriage with Tea Cake, a much younger soul, and things finally seemed to look up for her, even though she was still expected to help in the fields and tend to her womanly duties.

Overall, throughout her marriages, Janie experienced the hardships that most African American women went through at that time. From the physical labor to the physical beatings, Janie was presented with the life that a woman was expected to live.

She spends the novel seeking a voice for herself which she achieves in the end of her story. Later in her life, Janie is able to sit on her own porch and chat just like the men.

Throughout the novel, there is a strong use of dialect and colloquial language which reiterates that this is a story of a black woman from the South. Race[ edit ] While the novel is written about black people in the South, it is not primarily a book about racism.

Nanny is the first character to mention the notion of slavery. Dat's one of de hold-backs of slavery. Starks is compared to as the master of the plantation due to his huge house in the centre of the town. However his plans of creating a town in which blacks can live as equals creates a hierarchy between the townsfolk.

He don't have tuh. Us keeps our own selves down. Turner compliments Janie on her light skin and her Caucasian features. She disagrees with Janie's marriage to Tea Cake, since he is darker skinned with more African features.

Their Eyes Were Watching God Ch 17

Turner tries to get Janie to leave Tea Cake and marry her brother, Mr. This results in Tea Cake's jealousy and distrust of Mrs. She described falling in love with the man as "a parachute jump". Like Tea Cake, Punter was sexually dominant and sometimes violent. She wrote in her autobiography that she had "tried to embalm all the tenderness of [her] passion for him.

Ina decade before writing Their Eyes Were Watching God, Hurston traveled south to collect folk songs and folk tales through an anthropological research fellowship arranged by her Barnard College mentor Franz Boas. The town's weekly announced in"Colored People of the United States: Solve the great race problem by securing a home in Eatonville, Florida, a Negro city governed by negroes.